Less than 14% of immigrants arrested by ICE over the past year had charges or convictions for violent criminal offenses, according to data that Senator Dick Durbin cited during a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing this week. Durbin, the committee’s ranking Democrat, called the figure proof that the Trump administration’s mass deportation campaign has swept up far more than criminals — and is separating American families in the process.
The Numbers Behind the Controversy
The Trump administration launched one of the most aggressive immigration enforcement operations in modern American history starting in January 2025. The goal, officials said, was to remove criminals, gang members, and national security threats who had entered the country illegally. But Durbin’s reading of DHS data paints a different picture — one where the overwhelming majority of people being detained and deported don’t fit that description.
Durbin testified that fewer than 14 out of every 100 immigrants arrested by ICE had a violent criminal record. The rest — more than 86% — were detained based on civil immigration violations, meaning they entered or remained in the country without authorization but had no violent criminal history. He says that gap between the administration’s rhetoric and its actual enforcement record is what the American public isn’t being told.
Detention Conditions and DACA Deportations
Durbin didn’t stop at the numbers. He also raised alarm about conditions inside ICE detention facilities, citing a 2026 study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association. According to that study, the current detainee death rate inside ICE facilities is the highest ever recorded — exceeding even the death toll logged during the COVID-19 surge years. Durbin described scenes of what he called “unspeakable cruelty” targeting immigrant children and families in cities across the country.
Adding a flashpoint to the debate: DHS records show that at least 174 DACA recipients have been deported since January 2025. DACA — Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals — was created to protect individuals who were brought to the United States as children, often referred to as Dreamers. They grew up in America, attended American schools, and in many cases have no meaningful connection to their country of birth. Durbin says deporting DACA recipients is a direct violation of the program’s intent and has demanded written answers from DHS Secretary Kristi Noem on how these individuals were targeted.
The Administration Pushes Back
The Trump administration and its Republican allies in Congress reject the framing entirely. Their position is straightforward: every person being deported violated federal immigration law by entering or remaining in the country without authorization. They point to record-level illegal border crossings in recent years, rising public safety concerns in border communities, and what they describe as a near-total collapse of immigration enforcement under the Biden administration as justification for the aggressive approach. Officials argue they are not targeting innocent people — they are enforcing laws that already exist.
Republicans also push back on the DACA controversy, arguing that DACA itself was never passed into law by Congress — it was an executive action, and one they say the current administration has every legal right to wind down. That dispute has now escalated into a full constitutional standoff, with advocacy groups filing lawsuits and Durbin calling for emergency oversight hearings.
What This Means for Millions of Americans
This isn’t an abstract policy debate. There are an estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants living in the United States. Hundreds of thousands of them have American-born children, American spouses, and American employers. They pay taxes, own businesses, and have lived here for decades. If the 14% figure Durbin cites is accurate, it means the vast majority of people being removed are not the violent criminals the administration has described — they are workers, parents, and neighbors. Whether you believe the policy is right or wrong, the data is now the center of one of the most heated immigration fights this country has seen in a generation.
Stay informed on the stories that matter most. Follow Your Daily Updates on Facebook and bookmark yourdailyupdates.news for breaking news and analysis.